Stretching from nostalgic North Shore estates and antique North Chopstick wineries to the beachy Hamptons and Montauk’s laid-back luxe, Long Island offers trippers a different array of high-end hospices. Whether you seek major majesty on the Gold Coast, exchange closeness amid stations, or oceanfront serenity in Montauk, you’ll find it then.
This guide showcases the 6 Best hotels in Long Island, each offering signature dining, elegant lodging, and memorable original charm.
6 Best Hotels in Long Island
1. Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate – Huntington( North Shore)
Oheka Castle is a fabulous Châteauesque estate erected by financier Otto Kahn from 1914 – 1919, now converted into a luxurious 32-room hostel on the loftiest point of Long Island’s Gold Coast. Stepping outside is like entering a grand European manor house with bejeweled lyceums, manicured formal auditoriums, sweeping armature, and period details. Each room and suite elegantly blends major substance with ultramodern amenities, from plush coverlets and marble cataracts to in-room gym services and individualized service.
Beyond lodging, guests can enjoy guided manse tenures, autumn tea in refined surroundings, wine tastings, and large grounds for tromping or events. The hostel also caters to marriages and upmarket gatherings, buttressing its character as one of the region’s most iconic venues.
Best Dishes
At OHK Bar & Restaurant, hand plates include seasonal seafood risotto, condiment-caked angel loin, and indulgent goodies by Administrative Confection Cook Daniel Andreotti. Afternoon tea presents scones with clotted cream, cutlet sandwiches, and delicate afters
Location:
135 W Gate Drive, Huntington, NY 11743
Contact Number:
+1 631‑659‑1400
Email Address:
Website:
www.oheka.com
2. The Roundtree – Amagansett( Hamptons East End)
Set in literal charmed Amagansett, The Roundtree is Amagansett’s first true exchange luxury hostel, offering 15 intimate apartments, lodges, and suites amid lush auditoriums and serene meadows. Designed like a drinking guesthouse, the auberge features Scandinavian-inspired innards, crisp white screens, firepits, croquet meadows, and sportfisherman bikes for guests.
Morning brings a complimentary organic breakfast on the field — fresh fruit, afters, yogurt, granola, and original authorities — also biscotti and eyefuls served throughout the day. With just 15 units, The Roundtree feels exclusive yet relaxed, ideal for couples or small groups seeking barefoot luxury in a refined setting.
Best Dishes
Seasonal ranch-to-table breakfast with artisanal granola, original fruit, fresh-baked afters; light lunch options include avocado toast, summer salads, and hand lemonade.
Location:
Amagansett, East Hampton, NY
Contact Number:
(631) 267‑3133
Email Address:
guestservices@theroundtreehotels.com
Website:
theroundtreehotel.com
3. Marram Montauk – Montauk( East End)
Described as “ barefoot luxury, ” Marram Montauk is an exchange beachfront retreat nestled in the stacks east of Montauk city center. With natural wood homestretches, open couches, hammocks, and a serene café, and devoid of publicizing speakers, it appeals to guests seeking tranquility.
Apartments and suites feature breezy littoral décor, outdoor seating, and resort-position amenities with an emphasis on rest and heartiness. Morning yoga sessions, evening sand walks, and attentive yet understated service are emblems. Although not large, Marram’s design-forward morality and quiet air make it a swish escape for creative-inclined trippers.
Best Dishes
Fresh seafood dishes at the property café, including grilled fish tacos, ceviche, and seasonal salads with original vegetables and citrus-honey dressings.
Location:
Montauk, NY (on the dunes just east of downtown)
Contact Number:
(631) 668‑2050
Email Address:
hello@… / mostrador@…
Website:
marrammontauk.com
4. Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa – Montauk
An iconic oceanfront resort in Montauk, famed for its private sand and introducing seawater gym — the only beach-filtered seawater inner pool in North America. Firstly, Gurney’s Inn, the property, was exhaustively repaired and relaunched as a full-scale resort and gym destination.
Guests enjoy direct access to 2,000 bases of Atlantic beach, extensive sand club lounging, ocean-view pools, expansive gym treatments, fitness workrooms, cafes, and seasonal events. Elegant apartments and suites with littoral views punctuate classic design with deepwater traces.
Best Dishes
Seafood specialties like oysters, Maine lobster rolls, fresh ceviche, and amalgamations poolside or at oceanfront dining venues.
Location:
Montauk, NY
Contact Number:
1‑833‑235‑6500
Email Address:
info@gurneysresorts.com (inquiries via website)
Website:
gurneysresorts.com/montauk
5. Topping Rose House – Bridgehampton( Hamptons)
Housed in a major manor house, Beating Rose House blends grange fineness with ultramodern comfort and upmarket gym amenities. It features on- point ranch- to- table dining sourced from its own flower and vegetable auditoriums.
Guests are greeted by sophisticated décor, plush salons, yoga workrooms, and complimentary Lexus shuttles. With gym treatments, croft tenures, private estates, and epicurean existential dining, the property is a favorite for marriages and upmarket retreats.
Best Dishes
hand seasonal plates include handwrought pasta, vegetable squash blossoms, grilled seafood from original waters, and ranch-fresh salads, rounded by amalgamations and authorities made from theater yield.
Location:
Bridgehampton, NY
Contact Number:
(631) 808‑2000
Email Address:
reservations@toppingrosehouse.com (likely via contact)
Website:
toppingrosehouse.com
6. The Menhaden – Greenport( North Fork)
This 16-room exchange hostel in Greenport Village captures original littoral minimalism with ultramodern fineness and community feel. The Menhaden design palette centers on white walls, natural forestland, marine blue accentuations, and precisely curated vestiges like boats’ masts or old bottles.
Guests’ bottoms( galleys) are grazed with complimentary drinks and snacks, while bikes and electric transport options connect guests to Shelter Island and original stations. Rooftop bars and comfortable common areas elevate the hostel’s sociable yet peaceful vibe.
Best Dishes
Small plates in the guest-only eatery and rooftop bar — cured fish server, charcuterie from original crafters, seasonal vegetable dishes, and house-baked afters.
Location:
Front Street, Greenport Village, North Fork, Long Island
Contact Number:
(631) 333‑2777
Email Address:
info@themenhaden.com
Website:
themenhaden.com
Conclusion
From Oheka’s major majesty and Garden City’s elegant tradition, to exchange escapes like The Roundtree and The Menhaden, and sun-kissed oceanfront resorts in Montauk and the Hamptons, Long Island presents lodging for every taste.
Whether you are drawn to heartiness gyms, stupefied croft stays, deepwater luxury, or major complication these 6 Best hotels in Long Island offer hand dining, idyllic locales, and unmatched guests. Choose one or draft your perfect diary to savor the very best of Long Island’s hospitality.
Read More >> Best Hotels in New Hampshire